- In light of the C++11 threads threading option this is no longer
necessary for cross-platform threading support and did not offer a
noticeable performance gain over either the C++11 threads
implementation or OpenMP.
Change-Id: Icb588d520888c19a1775171795b55bcaffb3d256
Previously, the thread ID was acquired and released on every iteration
of the for loop. The C++11 concurrent queue implementation is much
slower than TBB's version and consequently this was a huge bottleneck.
This introduces another ParallelFor API which takes the thread ID as a
parameter in the evaluation function. This allows us to acquire and
release the thread ID for each block of work which drastically improves
the performance.
This change brings us on par with OpenMP and TBB. See below for a
timing comparison. Note: in this example this CLs C++11 version is
faster to compute the residuals because TBB still must acquire the
thread ID on every iteration, which has some overhead.
Tested by building and running tests for no threading, OpenMP, TBB, and
C++11 threads. Also ran bazel tests.
./bin/bundle_adjuster --input=problem-744-543562-pre.txt --num_threads=8
C++11 @Head
Time (in seconds):
Residual only evaluation 7.819692 (5)
Jacobian & residual evaluation 11.606063 (6)
Linear solver 47.860195 (5)
Minimizer 70.877072
Total 90.806338
---------------------------------------------------
C++11 (This CL)
Time (in seconds):
Residual only evaluation 1.217500 (5)
Jacobian & residual evaluation 5.796112 (6)
Linear solver 44.080873 (5)
Minimizer 54.635524
Total 77.640072
---------------------------------------------------
OpenMP
Time (in seconds):
Residual only evaluation 0.797023 (5)
Jacobian & residual evaluation 5.633916 (6)
Linear solver 43.280020 (5)
Minimizer 53.199058
Total 76.250861
---------------------------------------------------
TBB
Time (in seconds):
Residual only evaluation 1.911095 (5)
Jacobian & residual evaluation 5.557807 (6)
Linear solver 44.074680 (5)
Minimizer 55.002688
Total 78.052687
---------------------------------------------------
No Threads
Time (in seconds):
Residual only evaluation 2.939212 (5)
Jacobian & residual evaluation 18.519874 (6)
Linear solver 74.017837 (5)
Minimizer 98.980080
Total 122.216391
Change-Id: I3af959b0771bbdfe8cad8c13896191d6ac903181
Implements ParallelFor using the C++11 based ThreadPool. The C++11
parallel for is 50-70% faster than single threaded, and 20-30% slower
than TBB.
Tested by compiling with OpenMP, TBB, and C++11 Threading support and
ran the unit tests. Ran bazel as well.
Change-Id: I7fd6c9037ff9f200ce6999b5f39918995bb6b8ea
There are platforms where OpenMP is not available. This
patch adds support for Intel Threading Building Blocks (TBB)
as an alternative threading backend.
Change-Id: I94497d7cba0c3cfaccfc992169236f17fe948ae9
Alex Stewart